Skip to main content

Is Black Masculinity at the heart of Black Feminism?

Alice Childress' Wine in the Wilderness struck a discordant note with me. Towards the end of the play, Tommy has a phenomenal moment in the sun: raging against Bill, Old Timer, Sonny-Man, and Cynthia, she demonstrates the deep seated self-loathing at the heart of their progressive ethos. She strikes them in the same way that a mother would - with accuracy, care, and the intent to build up. While she calls them out for the way they abused her trust and misaligned her character, she also opens their eyes to reality of their societal position, demonstrating the ways in which the superiority they claimed was only functioning to reinforce the very negative stereotypes they were trying to escape. 

But right at the moment of Tommy's triumph, something strange occurs. She opens Bill's eyes to his rather misogynistic view of black women, showing that her living, breathing, existence was so much more than one simple swipe on a canvas. At this moment, Bill comes to the realisation that Tommy is right, and he promptly takes control of the reigns. Just as Tommy is about to triumphantly exit the space and leave the group to their collective shame, Bill pipes up and begins to wax poetic. The very first thing that he does is reorient the identities of the people around him - identities which, up until this point, were depicted as being inferior to his masculine, nationalistic, virile, artistic prowess. First, he reinforces Old Timer by using his real name (a name he was not aware of prior to Tommy's arrival). He then confronts Cynthia with the truth of her beauty, and makes an interesting rhetorical gesture by immediately linking it with Sonny-Man's masculinity. Tommy's exit is interrupted by Bill's apparent enlightenment, and the woman who was adamantly against posing in a mis-matched outfit is convinced to pose, holding the wig that was initially so abhorrent to Bill. The final line of the show (like the first one), is given to Bill, who engages in the artistic practise of composing a black female identity that is bolstered by an appeased black masculinity. 

This ending brings two ideas to mind - Amiri Baraka's brand of Black Nationalist Masculinity as explored byMatthew Rebhorn in his 2003 essay Flaying Dutchman: Masochism, Minstrelsy, and the Gender Politics of Amiri Baraka's Dutchman, and the 'Magical Negro' described by Glenn and Cunningham in their 2009 paper The Power of Black Magic: The Magical Negro and White Salvation in Film. Briefly, Rebhorn's paper speaks about how Baraka establishes black masculinity in Dutchman through a systematic subjugation of femininity and homosexuality, setting up an ethos which thrives on self-hatred and masochistic delight in othering. The Magical Negro is described as a shaman-like character whose wisdom, ethereality, and willingness to offer guidance is central to the success of white characters in mainstream films. The Magical Negro is described as a concession for misrepresentation, introducing black characters to films and television for the sake of inclusion, without dismantling the systems of social hierarchy which ensure that white subject hood remains the primary locus of identification. 

The end of this play undermines a powerful feminist self-actualisation by swiftly returning the role of primary subject to the black male during the moment of triumph. The decision to bring Tommy back into the room reads, not as a moment of powerful triumph, but as a reinforcement of the necessity of a black male figure as the foundation of black American identity. Bill's artistic triumph is not indicative of any real character growth, but rather a comfortable confirmation of his role and power as the crafter of the social world around him. Even in his moment of realisation (when he reads the definition of the 'N' word in the dictionary), the change is not the revelation of his own misogyny, but a revelation of Tommy's affection for him, despite his maltreatment of her. Bill realises that he is in fact, a _____ in the eyes of the world, but with Tommy's confession, there is no real shift of power. This leads to his eventual artistic anagnorisis, where he sees that the beautiful queen on the canvas is nothing but a fantasy. However, in his attempt to replace fantasy with reality, he fetishises Tommy's authenticity, replacing one fantasy with the other. The difference however, is that Tommy functions as a Magical Negro in this context, rather than a simple stereotype. Having shared her wisdom with the group, she is elevated for her wisdom and stripped of her voice. Having brought the protagonist to the well of knowledge, she is denied its pleasures and relegated to the sidelines with the consolation prize of temporal isolation.

Tommy's self-actualisation is co-opted by Bill, who reinforces his own superiority as the primary voice for a black identity, while he freezes her metamorphosis by taking advantage of her affections for him. This makes me wonder about the general message of the play. Are we supposed to view Bill's recognition of self as a moment of character development? What about the gross generalisation of African identities in the painting, and the lack of exploration when Bill realises his error? Does Cynthia receive the beauty that Bill so generously bestows on her? Or is she only beautiful when seated beside Sonny-Man in a picture of nuclear acquiescence? Does Old Timer's identity function as the reflection of a past he can never escape? What about his wisdom, experience, and potential contributions to civil rights struggles during challenging historical periods? Does Tommy really reclaim the sense of self that was robbed at the start of the play, or does she simply fulfil the purpose for which she was brought to Bill's studio? Is Black Masculinity the foundation of expressions of Black Feminism, or have they simply been co-opted into a black identity in which the male persona is de facto?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Passing Strange

Passing Strange was a crisis of faith realized, confronted, and lived through. As a woman of faith, it was difficult for me to see all the doubts that I have engaged with and heard in stolen whispers or defiant declarations and ignored, put up on the stage. The protagonist’s rebellion is something that I wish I had the stomach for. I was especially enamored by their travels and adventures in Europe – not the real Europe, but the one that you read about and hear about and fantasize about. The one where cigarettes give fashionable cancer, and alcoholism is merely a creative practice. The one where actions don’t have consequences, and you can live and let live – until it starts to feel real. I am not a musical person by any means, but the character themes and repeated refrains of metaphor, symbology, and imagery were nothing short of arresting. It was a beautiful picture of coming-of-age, maturity, loss, love, and regret – things I have too much of, but keep on seeking anyway. It’s the on...

What not to teach

 I have been ruminating on our lengthy discussion about Ayad Akhtar’s Disgraced, especially about the pedagogical ramifications of teaching this play. It just so happened that in the very same week as we were having our discussion, my Intro To Theatre class was reading the play for an assignment. Although the pedagogical premise of Talin Abadian’s article is rather weighty, I definitely appreciate the theoretical framework via which students may gain a deeper understanding of the text. However, it does not present enough practical applications outside of brief mentions of class discussions or student comments. It helped me to revisit the abstract of the article, because the author states their aim as using the play to pedagogically frame Orientalism, rather than using Orientalism to frame the play. In that regard, the article presents a formidable proposal for learning Said’s Orientalism and its applications to cultural studies through the play as a cultural artefact. As a tool for...

How pause in a world of go?

The session that we had with Dr. Rachel Aker this week made me reconsider how I often approach job applications and my general search for funding and academic opportunities. To be honest, I was struck with the emphasis on self-care in the materials that she sent us. My experience with seeking opportunities within academia has often been characterized by an urgent expediency. The time windows are brief, the application materials are vast and varying, and the requirements often emphasize what one lacks rather than what one possesses. The idea has always been to make oneself appear the most suitable by using the key words in the application prompt, or by employing some combination of self-aggrandizement and self-effacing obsequience. Such a combination requires mental gymnastics of the highest sort, and an persistent ability to receive negative feedback in the face of your best work, if you receive any feedback at all. All this to say, the application process has never been one that allow...