I have been ruminating on our lengthy discussion about Ayad Akhtar’s Disgraced, especially about the pedagogical ramifications of teaching this play. It just so happened that in the very same week as we were having our discussion, my Intro To Theatre class was reading the play for an assignment. Although the pedagogical premise of Talin Abadian’s article is rather weighty, I definitely appreciate the theoretical framework via which students may gain a deeper understanding of the text. However, it does not present enough practical applications outside of brief mentions of class discussions or student comments. It helped me to revisit the abstract of the article, because the author states their aim as using the play to pedagogically frame Orientalism, rather than using Orientalism to frame the play. In that regard, the article presents a formidable proposal for learning Said’s Orientalism and its applications to cultural studies through the play as a cultural artefact. As a tool for teaching Theatre students however, I think that it gets a little lost in the weeds. At the risk of sounding a little purist, I think that the script should be the beginning of understanding and analysis. The idea that ‘text is king’ can be problematic, but when approached from a pedagogical perspective, using the text as the place to begin may be the clearest way to get students to understand, and to relate to what is happening. I believe very strongly in the power of stories, especially in the theatre where these stories have life breathed into them as they happen. Having assigned this play to my students over the course of two classes, I would like to share how I go about this. I would love some feedback and/or suggestions for improvement!
This class is for non-majors, and students at every level of their four-year degree can take it. This means that I am getting a wide range of students with an even wider range of disciplines and experiences, from freshmen and seniors to military and older students who are returning to college. The play is assigned under an Audio Response Prompt, which uses adapted excerpts from Eleanor Fuchs’ Visit to a Small Planet as a question base. The assignment was conceived as an opportunity to give students an opportunity to speak back to plays for 30 seconds to a minute using guided questions, and to give me an opportunity to engage with student’s work in a more tangible way within an online class. Students are encouraged to write down their responses and read them into a recording tool, or to speak off the cuff. For this semester, the questions focused on the student’s emotional responses and thoughts before and after they read the play. Students’ responses were largely introspective, with many of them citing personal experiences of existing in uncomfortable identities, and a shifted perspective on what it means to be a Muslim man in post 9/11 America. Not surprisingly, very few of them cited 9/11 as a landmark shift, but many of them did briefly explore what it means to be ‘American’ in relation to the rest of the world, and what it means to navigate an ‘American’ identity within the current landscape. More importantly however, is the compassion that student’s exhibited for the protagonist. Many expressed feeling sorry for him, and noted the main issue of the play as Amir ‘trying to be something he is not’. This statement presents some opportunities to involve Orientalism as a theoretical guide – Amir is being othered, and the students note that in his attempt to escape this othering, is a defiant leap to whiteness that ultimatley leads to his downfall. This is something I might explore with students, were the class happening in person.
There are other nuances to the student’s responses, but this quick overview shows that there is room to incorporate theoretical frameworks by using the student’s own language as a starting point. I guess what I am trying to ask is; are there really plays that we should not teach? With common sense and guidance, I think that the stories of most plays carry them to interesting places of new understanding. Will students always ‘get it’? No. But will they hear a story and maybe see themselves and their world in it. Perhaps. It is not certain, but it is close enough
Comments
Post a Comment